Melissa’s Sweet Potato Casserole

The morning after my mother died a few months ago, my family and I were sitting around the table drinking coffee, still stunned, looking at our iPads and laptops, when one of my brothers said, “At least now Mom can go to Steve Jobs with all of her iPad questions.” We all burst out laughing. I still smile just thinking about it. We had a close relationship with our mother and embedded in that relationship was the job of answering her computer questions. Well, every year, a few days before Thanksgiving, I could expect an email from my mother that went like this, “Judy, could you send me the recipes?” I knew which ones they were: Mom’s Pumpkin Pie, Micky Kohn’s Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie, Grandma’s Cranberry Chutney and this one, Melissa’s Sweet Potato Casserole. Mom did not have a clue how to search her computer for them. In honor of Mom and to help my family get through the holidays, I plan to post the rest of Mom’s Thanksgiving recipes over the next few days. If there is a kitchen in heaven, she and Steve are by now best buds, and he’ll be stopping by her table that will be full of the family and friends who have gone before us. My brothers and I will be thankful we have her recipes and that we had the privilege of calling her Mom.


I’ve been making this sweet potato casserole every Thanksgiving since 1994 when my children’s fabulous babysitter, Melissa, first gave it to me. Little did I know I would be making it every Thanksgiving for the rest of my life.

Yield: serves 12 as a main side dish or 20 as one of many side dishes

4 pounds sweet potatoes, peeled
5 large eggs, beaten
½ cup granulated sugar
¾ cup (12 tablespoons, or 1-1/2 sticks) butter, melted
1 tablespoon vanilla extract
²/3 cup milk
½ cup orange juice
Mise en Place:
Preheat oven to 350º
Wash and peel sweet potatoes. Cut into 2-3 inch chunks and place in a large saucepan.
Cover potatoes with cold water. Add two tablespoons of salt to the water.
Bring water to a boil and cook for about 15 minutes or until sweet potatoes are fork-tender.
Drain in a colander and allow to cool for about 30 minutes.
Place sweet potatoes in a mixing bowl and mix until mashed. Do not whip.
DSC_0075 DSC_0076
Add eggs, sugar, butter, vanilla, milk, and orange juice and mix until well blended on medium-low speed. Do not whip.
DSC_0103 DSC_0104
Transfer sweet potato mixture to an oven-safe 9x12x4 casserole. At this point, you could put the uncooked casserole into the refrigerator for up to one day as a make-ahead dish. Just be sure to allow it to come to room temperature before baking. Do not add toppings until after it has baked.
Bake until the top starts to turn light brown and a knife inserted in the center comes out clean. This usually takes about an hour in this deep casserole dish. If you are using two shallow casserole dishes, it could be ready in 30 minutes.
The toppings below are optional. Because some of our guests may have a nut allergy, I generally opt for the marshmallow topping, but the nut topping is equally delicious.
Optional Marshmallow Topping:
When finished cooking, remove casserole from oven and add a layer of miniature marshmallows. Bake for another 10 minutes or until marshmallows become lightly browned.
DSC_0164 DSC_0187
Optional Nut Topping:
1 cup brown sugar
½ cup all-purpose flour
½ stick butter (4 tablespoons)
1 cup chopped pecans
Mix until crumbly. Sprinkle on top of cooked casserole. Bake for 10 minutes at 400º.
This casserole is good cold the next morning, and if you are anything like me, you’ll be thinking about grabbing a spoonful of it every time you walk by the refrigerator.


Follow my photos of vegetables growing, backyard chickens hanging out, and dinner preparations on Instagram at JudysChickens.

Never miss a post: sign up to become a follower of the Blog.

© 2014-2017 Judy Wright. All rights reserved. Photos and text may only be used with written consent.

19 thoughts on “Melissa’s Sweet Potato Casserole

  1. You have such a beautiful way with words! Always love your blog and especially today with the tribute to your mother! Looking forward to the rest of your treasured recipes. Jane Clay

  2. Know I will be thinking of you and your family!

    I need a pumpkin pie recipe. This is the first time in 30 years I have not posted Thanksgiving. I am going to a friends house. And we’re smoking two turkey breast and I have been asked to bring a pumpkin pie.

    I wasn’t sure if you had posted it yet. Hope to see you in class Hugs Mary Helen

    Sent from my iPhone


    1. Mary Helen, my favorite no-fail pumpkin pie recipe is on the blog under Mom’s Pumpkin Pie. Soon I’ll post my other favorite pumpkin pie, a cheesecake pie. It’s excellent. These are the two pies I make every Thanksgiving. Thank goodness for your Jazzercise classes or I would be a blimp!

  3. Love this story, Judy ! You were all so attentive to Auntie Mary , love that ! Can just hear her asking ….xoxoCarol

    Sent from my iPhone


  4. I can’t wait to try this! Love all versions of sweet potato casserole and still on search for the prefect one. Surprised it does not have cinnamon…..

    1. Thanks, Meera. I like the taste of sweet potato, as is, unlike pumpkin which I think needs lots of spices to be flavorful. I would suggest trying it without cinnamon at first and if you think it needs it, add it the next time you make it.
      Great event on dealing with the issue of hunger in Nashville, yesterday!

    1. Good question. I would tend to doubt it. Better to bake it first, without the topping, and store in fridge. I cooked mine on Tuesday and 48 hours later, the leftovers are still delicious.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s